It has been too long, my friends; I have missed you. Reuben aficionados have been wandering the streets not knowing what to do or what to order. For those of you who lost faith in the Reuben and ended up playing it safe and ordering a Turkey Wrap, I apologize. You should never have to do that.
I’m back and I hit up a Reuben next door in Grapevine at Weinberger’s Deli. This place has 180 Google Reviews (4.5 stars), 293 Yelps (4.5 stars) so I am not discovering a hidden gem here, but they seem to be known for the Italian Beef and not necessarily the Reuben. It’s a big risk ordering a Reuben when apparently the Italian Beef is so good and fun to order.
“Hot Corned Beef and Pastrami, Melted Swiss Cheese, Russian Dressing, Sauerkraut, Grilled Marble Rye”
Appearance – (3.7/5.0)
Nothing spectacular here. I think the chip portion could have been more generous. I held it up to give a better view. It looks like the volcano of sauerkraut has displaced the section of meat and shifted it over. The Swiss cheese is present and accounted for and there is just a hint of the dressing.
Quality of Ingredients – (4.4/5.0)
I was really pleased with all of the ingredients on the plate. I even ate the pickle and I’m not usually a pickle person. The Russian Dressing really stood out. I thought it gave a great kick to the Reuben. There was a lost diced onion piece on the first picture of the Reuben. I thought it meant the product was homemade. Then I looked up at the shelf. Nope. They must have a good supplier but for some reason keep the label hidden. Company secret.
The meat and cheese is also bought and displayed in a deli case when you walk in the door. The Swiss Cheese was thick and good. I was impressed they were able to get a good melt on all the cheese without completely burning the bread. I like a bit of char but it’s a slippery slope.
The sign said Corned Beef AND Pastrami. I can’t really tell if I got both. I know. I’m a fraud. I think it was Corned Beef. Either way, I liked it.
Price – (4.2/5.0)
$8.99 is pretty good. I think a few more chips could have gone a long way here. The portion of meat is fair but not huge. We are in North Texas but in “downtown” Grapevine so I understand if the price is a bit higher.
Je Ne Sais Quoi – (4.7/5.0)
This place has a great vibe. I don’t know of too many Chicago delis in town (Don’t call it a New York Deli). The owner was very friendly and it had a great Mom-n-Pop feel to it. There are signs everywhere about the Italian Beef so I felt strange not ordering it. It also gets extra points for the super melty cheese stretching across the table as I took the first bite.
Taste – (9.5/10.0)
Hello! So it may not be much to look at but this was a great Reuben. Solid execution and put together with love. You don’t need excessive piles of meat or needlessly fancy ingredients. There are a few basic ingredients that they handled well. The Panini press was used to perfection. It melted the cheese and warmed the meat up just right.
Overall – (26.5/30.0)
Would I order it again? Yes, but I may have to come back for the Italian Beef first. I got a taste of the Rachel on my way out the door and that was great too. They put it on Pumpernickel bread. Downtown Grapevine is a great little place, Main St USA. I hope to be back soon!